Stove Repair vs Replace: When to Fix It or Get a New One

When your stove, a key appliance used daily for cooking, often with electric or gas burners and an oven. Also known as a cooktop or range, it’s one of the most used appliances in the home. stops working, you’re left with a tough call: repair it or buy new? It’s not just about price—it’s about safety, efficiency, and how long it’ll last after the fix. Many people jump to replace because they think repairs are too expensive, but that’s not always true. A simple igniter replacement on a gas stove can cost under £80 and bring it back to life for another 5–8 years. On the other hand, a brand-new stove can set you back £500–£1,500, depending on features and brand.

Not all stove problems need a full replacement. oven control board, the electronic brain that manages temperature and settings failures are common, especially in older models, but replacing it often costs less than half of a new unit. If your stove heats unevenly, takes forever to light, or shows error codes, those are fixable issues—not reasons to throw it out. But if the heating elements are cracked, the oven door won’t seal, or the control panel is completely dead, those are signs the unit is near the end of its life. Most stoves last 10–15 years. If yours is 12+ years old and needing multiple repairs, replacement might be smarter long-term.

Then there’s the appliance repair cost, the total price of fixing a broken appliance including parts, labor, and diagnostics. A technician might charge £60–£100 just to come out, and parts can add up fast. If the repair bill hits 50% of what a new stove costs, it’s usually time to replace. Also, newer models use 20–30% less energy. If your current stove is older than 10 years, you’re likely wasting money on high electricity or gas bills every month. That adds up over time.

Don’t forget safety. A gas stove with a faulty igniter can leak gas. An electric stove with damaged wiring can spark. Repairs aren’t just about saving cash—they’re about keeping your home safe. A professional can spot hidden issues you can’t see, like worn insulation or corroded connections. But if you’ve had three repairs in two years, you’re probably just buying time.

Below, you’ll find real-world guides on diagnosing common stove problems, checking if a control board is worth replacing, and how to tell if your oven’s lifespan is over. We’ve pulled data from hundreds of actual repair jobs to show you exactly when it’s smarter to fix it—and when it’s time to let go.