Repair vs Replace Stove: Quick Guide to the Best Decision
You've got a stove that’s acting up – maybe the burners are flaky, the oven won’t heat, or strange noises are popping up. Before you rush to the hardware store or call a technician, take a moment to weigh the facts. This guide breaks down the most important things to look at, so you can decide if a fix will save you money or if a brand‑new stove is the smarter move.
How to Decide: Key Factors to Check
Age of the appliance. Most stoves last between 10 and 15 years if you keep up with regular maintenance. If yours is older than that, parts may be harder to find and the overall efficiency will be lower. A newer model can use less energy and cook more evenly, which adds up on your electricity or gas bill.
Frequency of problems. One odd glitch might be a simple fix – a blown fuse, a cracked igniter, or a loose gas valve. But if the stove has needed several repairs in the past year, the cost of each fix can quickly surpass the price of a new unit.
Safety concerns. Gas leaks, cracked glass, or faulty wiring are not just inconveniences; they’re hazards. If any repair involves the gas line or electrical components, you should get a qualified professional to assess whether the stove is still safe to use.
Energy efficiency. Modern stoves often have induction burners or better insulated ovens, which can cut cooking time and lower utility costs. If your old stove is a big energy guzzler, a replacement might pay for itself in a few years.
Cost Comparison: Repair vs New Stove
Typical stove repairs range from £80 for a simple igniter swap to £250 for a major gas valve replacement. If the fix is under £150 and your stove is less than 10 years old, repairing is usually the better bet.
Buying a new stove can cost anywhere from £300 for a basic electric model to £1,200 for a high‑end gas or induction unit. Add delivery and installation, and you’re looking at £400‑£1,400 total. Compare that to the repair quote and think about how long the new stove will last – most come with a 2‑year parts guarantee and a 5‑year warranty on the main components.
Factor in hidden costs too. Older stoves might need a new vent hood or additional wiring work to meet current regulations, which can add £100‑£200. A brand‑new stove often comes with built‑in safety features that eliminate those extras.
In short, use this quick test: If the repair cost is less than 30‑40% of a new stove’s price, and the appliance is under ten years old, repair it. If it’s older, has recurring issues, or the repair approaches half the price of a new unit, start looking at replacements.
Whatever you choose, make sure the work is done by a qualified technician. A proper fix will keep you cooking safely and avoid surprise breakdowns later. And if you decide to go new, pick a model that fits your cooking style and budget, and ask about energy‑saving features – they can make a real difference on your monthly bills.
Bottom line: Don’t let a stubborn stove dictate your kitchen schedule. Check the age, safety, and repair costs, compare them to the price of a new model, and you’ll have a clear answer. Your stove should help you cook, not stress you out.
Yes-most electric stoves are repairable. Learn what usually fails, safe DIY checks, NZ repair costs, when to replace, and how induction vs ceramic vs coil models differ.